How Do Exposure Therapies Work?

If you research treatment for mental health issues like anxiety, phobias, OCD, and trauma, you will find a lot of references to "exposure" therapies. As someone who specializes in exposure-based interventions, I wanted to provide some information about exposure strategies and how they might be helpful. The information below is a brief, general, and incomplete description of exposure-based interventions. It is merely an introduction to the concepts.
What are exposure-based interventions? Exposure-based interventions disrupt the factors that maintain anxiety (e.g., safety behaviors, avoidance, rituals, compulsions, etc.). They allow individuals to encounter distressing thoughts, images, activities, events, memories, urges, etc. in a way that over time those triggers become less distressing. Individuals who benefit from exposure strategies feel more confident, reclaim freedom, improve quality of life and functioning, and can spend that time and energy on leading a meaningful life. Exposure strategies are a mixture of real-life (in-vivo) and imaginal activities, sometimes accompanied by training in anxiety management strategies (e.g., diaphragmatic breathing, mindfulness, progressive muscle relaxation, etc.). By strategically practicing certain behaviors, you can decrease your distress and anxiety over time.
Can you give me some examples? Exposure and response prevention is often used for treating OCD by designing a way to disrupt the link between the intrusive thought and the compulsion or ritual designed to neutralize the distress or prevent the feared negative outcome. For contamination obsessions, this could involve "spoiling" your clean hands after over-washing by touching a "dirty" surface and resisting washing them again. Someone with agoraphobia symptoms could take an unfamiliar route to a familiar location. Imaginal exposures are done when the actual practice would be too intense or when it involves something that cannot be practiced. For example, someone with a trauma history may read or visualize a detailed scenario about a multi-car traffic accident.
How does it help? One of the universal components addressed by these interventions is overt and covert avoidance. Those are the big and small ways that we try and stay "safe" and navigate distressing feelings and uncertain - avoiding the distressing thing altogether. Imagine cancelling plans for an event you are dreading. You feel an immediate sense of relief. Used sporadically, that type of avoidance may be a valid, functional strategy. However, in the long-term context of social anxiety that can result in sacrificing most meaningful activities and opportunities to connect. Over time that worsens anxiety and shrinks our comfort zone to the point that most social interactions are accompanied by intense anxiety or avoided altogether. We get stuck in a cycle where to escape the anxiety, we must continue to avoid which makes it more likely we will get anxious and avoid again in the future.
It sounds like you are saying, "Just do it!" I've tried to face my fears in the past and it didn't work. Exposure isn't about randomly throwing yourself into overwhelming and scary situations and hoping for the best*. It's about doing something that pushes your comfort zone in an intentional, replicable, and definable way until your mind and body learn not to respond so intensely and to stop viewing the trigger as a threat. This process builds confidence, comfort, and decreases your autonomic nervous system's anxiety response to perceived "threats." Over time, with repeated practice, you experience less anxiety. The reason that most people do scary things and still feel anxious is that they 1) engage in the activity in a way that prevents them from actually overcoming the anxiety (e.g., they went to the party but didn't talk to anyone, they leave their house but only with a "safe" person who does the driving) or 2) they do it so inconsistently that when it happens, they just try to "survive" the experience without ever acclimating or habituating to it. In short, we don't do it enough in the right way to get the result we want.
That sounds unpleasant and scary. Didn't you hear that I am terrified all the time? It is true that some people discontinue exposure therapy due to their reaction to the interventions, but that is about the same number of people who discontinue normal counseling for other reasons. The key with exposure therapy is that it needs to be intentional, predictable, and replicable. It also helps to do with the someone you trust and who has your best interest in mind. The more collaboratively we create the treatment blueprint (e.g., fear and avoidance hierarchy) the more accurately we can predict how the process goes and the more we learn about what you need from an exposure to be meaningful. We collaboratively create clearly defined exposures that take into account your comfort level, confidence, capacity, and motivation. We don't want to set anyone up for failure. We use a scale called SUDS (Subjective Units of Distress from 0-100). We don't assign someone new to exposure therapy to a 75. We would start with a 20-25, something meaningful but doable. If someone has agoraphobia, we don't start by sending them to Walmart alone on Black Friday, we might start with them walking their dog around the block alone. Understanding how your symptoms manifests helps us to specifically tailor the exposures. Walking with your dog around the block alone might be a 35, but if you choose to leave your phone at home, it might be a 55. Walking around the block with someone you know and trust might make it a 15. By being deliberate and curious, we can create meaningful and effective exposures while limiting unwanted surprises.
So, it's all about practicing the things we fear? At the core, exposure is about about practicing things that make us distressed until our distress decreases. However, there are other factors at play and positive outcomes that occur throughout the process of engaging in exposures.
Gathering evidence and testing hypotheses - Sometimes we avoid something beforehand which prevents us from learning what would happen. If I assume what someone thinks instead of directly asking for feedback, if I avoid asking the person out to lunch, if I don't accept the invitation, or I don't apply for the job, I am left with the predictions and stories that my anxiety tells me instead of learning what would actually happen. The more you practice exposures, the more evidence you have to inform your perception and predictions. The more information you gather, the better those will be. Research on anxiety has shown that anxiety overestimates the likelihood of something negative happening, underestimates our ability to handle that, and interprets neutral situations as negative and threatening. If you are going to live your life and make decisions based on predictions, those predictions should be accurate and functional. Exposures give you a chance to test the hypotheses. For example, if I have to give a speech my anxiety might be telling me, "If I give that speech, I'm going to make a fool out of myself, look like an idiot, pass out or throw up, and everyone will laugh at me and it will ruin my career." I need to give that speech to see if the experience, quality, outcome, and process go as predicted. It rarely, if ever does turn out as badly as anxiety predicts. It also is the best way to see if your predictions are accurate.
Testing your capabilities and developing competence - The long-term byproduct of uncertainty and dread, along with avoidance, can lead to feeling pathetic, unconfident, indecisive, and/or incapable. Most clients initially rate their potential exposures on the SUDS scale significantly higher than they actually feel when they practice the activity in real-life. Anxiety makes those things feel overwhelming, but when we face our fears, we get to see our actual response and capability in that situation. No one feels confident the first time they are doing something new and scary. Confidence is a by product of repeatedly engaging in the behaviors that lead to feelings of confidence. You might also learn something about yourself that is a strength or talent, or a potential deficit that you can improve through practice. We are what we practice. If we want to become more patient, we practice patience. If we want to become kinder, we practice kindness. If we want to be physically stronger, we engage in activities that build our strength. Engaging in meaningful exposures actually develops competence over time. If you have anxiety about public speaking, your first speech won't be the best speech you ever deliver. However, you can develop the skill of public speaking while you are engaging in the process of addressing your public speaking anxiety. It's the same with setting healthy boundaries, saying no, giving and receiving feedback, taking risks, learning a new skill, etc.
Desensitization and habituation - The ultimate byproduct of consistently engaging in exposures is that the previously feared or distressing trigger doesn't evoke the same intense feelings. Over time, our mind and body learns that it isn't actually dangerous, the feared outcome won't happen, or that we can actually handle it better than predicted.
If you are interested in learning more about how these strategies may be helpful in managing your symptoms, schedule a free consultation.
*There is a technique called flooding that does involve you facing your fears in a maximally intense way, but I've never used flooding in my clinical work. If employed clinically, it needs to be done ethically, collaboratively, and strategically with a clinician who is specializes in that intervention.




